Count the winning squares before you name a double threat

Columns run from A to O, including I, left to right. Rows run from 1 to 15, bottom to top. Same system as the shapes page. When one move joins two lines, mark every square that would complete five. A line already closed at both ends has none. In the first diagram the ringed stone is H8, just played. On the rank, E8, F8, G8, and H8 are four black stones, and D8 is already white, so teal I8 is the only square that completes five. On the file, H7, H8, and H9 are three black stones, but H6 and H10 are already white, so that file has no winning square. White only needs to take I8. This is not two defensive points.

The second diagram is a different game, the same double-three diagram as the shapes page. Ringed H8 makes two open threes. The rank F8, G8, H8 has teal ends at E8 and I8. The file H7, H8, H9 has teal ends at H6 and H10. Four different points, and one stone cannot cover them. The move is legal here. If White takes only one end, the other open three remains, and Black’s next move can make a four whose both ends complete five.

The ring is H8. Teal I8 is the only square that completes five. H6 and H10 are already white, so the file has no winning square.
The ring is H8. Rank ends E8 and I8, file ends H6 and H10. Four teal points, and one stone cannot cover them.

Take the shared empty square while it is still empty

The forcing move is usually built before it is played. The next two diagrams are one game. They are not the diagrams in “Count the winning squares before you name a double threat”. On the rank, E8, F8, and H8, and on the file, G9 and G7, all point at empty G8. F9 is already white. Teal G8 is not a winning square now.

If Black takes G8, the rank becomes E8, F8, G8, H8. D8 already blocks one end, and only I8 completes five. The file becomes G7, G8, G9, with G6 and G10 both empty. That is a four-three: a forcing four plus an open three. Those defensive points are not the same square. In the second diagram White takes G8 first. The rank breaks between F8 and H8. The file breaks between G9 and G7. That white stone also makes a diagonal pair with F9.

Teal G8 is the empty square both lines share. It is not a winning square now. F9 is already white.
White on G8 breaks both lines, and pairs on the diagonal with F9.

Rank the reply after the double threat lands

When the shared point is already taken, use this order. If you can complete five now, do that. Next, a forcing four of your own that the opponent must answer. Next, whether one stone covers both threat points. If none of those, blocking only one line usually delays the loss by one move. The first diagram is the game in “Take the shared empty square while it is still empty” if G8 was not taken first. Ringed G8 has been played. White has no five and no forcing four of their own on this diagram. Winning square I8, and the open-three ends G6 and G10, are not the same point. G6 and G10 are still empty; they are not the winning square of this move. White can only take I8 first. Taking I8 does not remove the open three.

After I8 is taken, Black plays G10, the ring. The file G7, G8, G9, G10 is four black stones. Teal G6 and G11 are both empty and both complete five, so this file is an open four. White can occupy only one: take G6 and Black plays G11 for five; take G11 and Black plays G6 for five. The rank from E8 to H8 now has white on D8 and on I8, so it is no longer a line that makes five. If White makes an ordinary open three somewhere else instead, Black can ignore it and play the remaining winning square.

The ring is G8. Teal I8 is the winning square of this move. G6 and G10 are still empty, and they are not the same point as I8.
The ring is G10. Teal G6 and G11 are both empty and both complete five. White can take only one of them.

Two positions worth recognizing

The file is already closed, so only I8 remains

In “Count the winning squares before you name a double threat”, the first diagram rings H8, just played. E8, F8, G8, and H8 are four black stones, D8 is already white, and teal I8 is the only square that completes five. H6 and H10 are already white, so that file has no winning square, and White only needs to take I8.

One block still leaves a five at the other end

In “Rank the reply after the double threat lands”, the second diagram has white on I8 and the ring on G10. G7, G8, G9, and G10 are four black stones. Teal G6 and G11 both complete five. Take G6 and Black plays G11 for five; take G11 and Black plays G6 for five.

Check these three points before you play

  1. Mark the winning squares before calling it a double threat. The first diagram in “Count the winning squares before you name a double threat” has only I8. The double three has four different points: E8, I8, H6, H10. Those four are the ends of the open threes, not squares that already complete five.
  2. If you can make five, do that first. In the first diagram of “Rank the reply after the double threat lands”, White has no five, so White blocks I8; after that block the open three still becomes an open four.
  3. An ordinary open three does not take the turn back from an open four. The second diagram in “Rank the reply after the double threat lands” wins on G6 and G11. An open three elsewhere still lets Black play the other end for five.

Common Gomoku Questions

Is a double three always already a win?

Not always. The second diagram in “Count the winning squares before you name a double threat” is two open threes. E8, I8, H6, and H10 are all different, one stone cannot finish the defense, the move is legal here, and White is already losing. The first diagram there also has a file of three black stones, but H6 and H10 are white, so that is not a double threat. If the opponent can complete five first, or play a forcing four that must be answered, answer that first.

Why can an open four usually not be stopped?

The second diagram in “Rank the reply after the double threat lands” shows it: G7 through G10, and the ends G6 and G11 both complete five on the next move. One stone per turn. Take G6, Black plays G11. Take G11, Black plays G6. The only exception is White completing five on this same turn.

Which point do you take while the double threat is still being built?

While it is empty, take G8 from “Take the shared empty square while it is still empty”. It breaks both the rank and the file. Once the position is the first diagram in “Rank the reply after the double threat lands”, White has no five and can only take I8 first; that block does not remove the open three on the file.

How do you see it earlier?

Replay a lost game and stop before the opponent occupies a point like G8. Write down the stones that point at it. The first diagram in “Take the shared empty square while it is still empty” is E8, F8, H8, and G9, G7. Find that empty point before counting long lines.